News

Sikhs losing tradition in translation.

News Source: www.fresnobee.com

Over the last two decades, the Valley's Indian immigrants have built at least a dozen Sikh temples to serve a growing community.

But many temples are often short of one thing: young adults, some of whom say they feel like outsiders.

They don't like the temple politics and don't have command of Punjabi, the primary language of the service.

They want more youth activities and projects to keep them interested.

"There's a generational divide," said 27-year-old Naindeep Singh, regional leader of the Jakara Movement, a nonprofit Sikh youth organization.

Singh, who is from Madera, said most of the parents are immigrants who observe the religion as they did in India, reciting memorized verses. Many of the youths want a more Americanized service that allows for discussion and explanation.

"It's evolving, but it hasn't evolved at a point where it's engaging the youth," Singh said.

Last month, the generational divide was the focus of the Jakara Movement's annual Sikh Youth Conference held at California State University, Fresno. Participants agreed to ask their temples to make more accommodations for young adults.

Some Sikh elders say younger Sikhs should master Punjabi because it's central to the culture and faith.

Still, those elders agree that changes are needed.

Ranjit Singh Rajpal, general secretary of the Sikh Council of Central California who emigrated from India to the United States in 1974, said most temples offer English translations of hymns and of the holy book, the Guru Granth Sahib, to address concerns of younger adults. Most temples also offer Punjabi language classes.

But Rajpal said youths who are in charge of providing English translations at some temples don't always stick with it. On some Sundays, there's no projector for the translations because the operator didn't show up, he said.

Rajpal, who is 58, also blamed parents for not pushing their children to learn Punjabi and go to the temple.

"The parents are not worried about that or are busy with other things -- working and trying to settle down," he said. "That's what's causing the feeling among the youth."

Parminder Singh, 38, of Kingsburg, agrees that parents must do more to teach their children Punjabi and the Sikh faith.

"Anytime you translate, you lose some meaning. We have to be bilingual," said Singh, whose wife is teaching Punjabi to their two children, ages 10 and 7.

Penny Mirigian-Emerzian, secretary of the Fresno chapter of the Armenian American Citizens League, said Armenian immigrants went through the same thing when their U.S.-born children were exposed to American culture.

"In the Armenian situation, the second generation of young Armenians did not know how to read and write in Armenian and resisted learning it," she said.

Mirigian-Emerzian, 86, said her parents forced her to go to an Armenian school, and she attended Valley Armenian churches, where the services were in Armenian.

"My parents retained the custom and spoke the language well, but I was born and raised here. As a young kid, I didn't want to learn Armenian, but as I grew up, I realized it was an advantage to learn another language," she said. "I wanted to be American. I thought why should I speak something else?"

Conflicts between immigrants and their children over religious traditions are not uncommon, said Rudy Busto, a professor of religious studies at the University of California at Santa Barbara.

"This is very typical of what happens in the second generation. The usual model ... is the immigrant church or religious institution is tied to the old country," Busto said. The younger generation is torn between their parents' traditions and their own Americanized values.

The younger generation "will adapt the tradition in ways that allow them to be both Sikhs and Americans," Busto said.

The Valley is home to about 40,000 Sikhs. The principles of Sikhism, a religion founded more than 500 years ago in Punjab, India, and what is now Pakistan, includes belief in one God, truthful living and the equality of mankind.

At a typical temple, called a Gurdwara in Punjabi, men and women sit barefoot on the floor on opposite sides during the Sunday service. Hymns are sung in Punjabi followed by prayer.

Harjinder Dhillon, president of the executive committee of Singh Sabha Gurdwara in Fresno, acknowledged that some temples are resistant to change.

"Some temples are so strict. There's no cultural dances and plays. They say it's bad to incorporate those things," he said.

Dhillon hopes the new temple Singh Sabha Gurdwara is building will appeal to younger adults.

The temple on Parkway Drive between Ashlan and Shaw avenues will feature an educational institute, a gym, tennis courts, a playground and a prayer room.

The $10 million first phase is scheduled to be completed by next summer.

Dhillon foresees more Valley temples adapting to the next generation of Sikhs.

"If they don't adapt to the changing times, the temples will fade away with the older generation," Dhillon said. "We have to listen to their concerns."


- By Vanessa Colón / The Fresno Bee

 The reporter can be reached at vcolon@fresnobee.com or (559) 441-6313.

 

 

one thing

Satnam M Singh Ji, In no way would I defend drinking and bad behaviour on a Gurdwara premises. But at the same time the stance of an outright ban on dancing and suggesting that dancing is anti-gurmat which is what some sikhs go to the extremes of saying is also not gurmat. Gurmat is the middle path... and maybe Punjabis just make a mess of a good thing but for example we have yoga centres in the UK which can have yogi dance nights which are free from alcolhol, drugs and smoking and people enjoy themselves dancing... and it is such a wonderful way to relax and unwind especially after a long days work! Gyming, martial arts would also be equally cool...all are great Singh ji...not all dance places are bump&grind lol! This would be like Richard Dawkins who belives that religion is bad because it creates extreme thinking in people i.e. suicide bombers... sure some people dont interpret religion correctly but to suggest religion is outright bad is incorrect. Dancing at a dance class is a completly different atmosphere... to be honest our whole punjabi community is full of theory and practice....e.g. treat people equally yet our parents scream at intercaste marriage, gender equality yet look at the gender ratio in our gurdwaras, treating sons and daughters equally yet look at the sex ration in punjab etc etc...our whole community has theory and practice which are poles apart. It doesn't however make the theory bad - our aim is to make or should be to make theory reality blessings and love to you www.ProjectNaad.com

During Guru Angad Dev's

During Guru Angad Dev's time, He set an example of physical well being being promoted from Gurdwara premises, with sports. So Gym and martial arts are fine. Because they have been promoted by Guru sahib themselves... But can you name one incident where dancing was allowed in Gurdwara by Guru sahib ? I do remember a dancing event in Harmandhir sahib by Messa Ranghar, and he was beheaded by sikhs. But of course everything has to change with times. Right ? The thing is if today you think dancing is not too bad and allowable, your son might be thinking that having eggs in Gurdwara is alright too. Afterall, many people classify eggs as vegetarian meal too. And your grandson probably would think wine is ok too, since its from grapes only. So where do we draw the line between personal thought and Guru's thought ? End of day, Gurudwara is Guru's house. Its not your house. You decide on your house regulations. But pls do not change Guru sahib's regulations in His own house. If dancing was to be allowed in Gurdwara, in the long span of the lives of our 10 Gurus there was bound to be at least one incident where it was allowed. Have some fear of Guru sahib. He is very kind. But if you want to carry the burden of bad karam on your head, dont blame Guru sahib for what is to come for you. That said, no one is stopping you from organising an alcohol free community dance event for you family at countless community clubs.

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA,

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH God bless your innocence. Tell you what, when the Gurudwara is built and established for a few years, go to one of their "cultural dances". You'll get your answer. I doubt they would dance in the spiritual estacy that is described in the Guru Granth Sahib. Rather, "Aja Nach Leh" (sorry, I am not aware of all of the modern Punjabi Geet) or the most current remix with Puff Daddy Bhangra-Rap is blasting in the same sanctuary as Guru Sahib, promise me you'll be there to defend your brochure then. Aerobics and dance studio? Well, defend it at the next bump and grind - coming soon at a Gurudwara near you. Don't believe me? Just wait. And please spare me that it is a good way to attract the youth. Do you see churches printing posters of semi nude women to attract people to the next service? The point of the Gurudwara is to connect people with the Almighty. If you think that dancing will not affect the type of Sangat there, you have another thing coming. And just to place this in context...I live in the area of this story. In fact, the new Gurudwara will be in my backyard. Fresno has so many Gurudwarae because different types of Sangat goes to different Gurudwarae. There are plenty of "eat langar and go home" Gurudwarae, plenty of Gurudwarae violating Hukamnamae, and even those who have the nerve to flat out defy the Akal Thakt and getting ready to build a "community hall" (read alcohol, dancing and manmukhness ON THE SAME PROPERTY as the Gurudwarae). Because of this prevalence, there were groups of Sangat that finally gave up and left to form their own Gurudwarae to acually do some Bhagti and Kirtan, rather than the weekend Pakhand that goes on in many Gurudwarae. So please spare me your theories...I live here and know what is going on in this neighborhood. I know the types of "cultural dances" will be going on here. Don't make assertions on something that you are miles upon miles away from. As I said, God Bless your innocence. May you never wake up from it. If you do, you will come to a realization that theory and practicality are eons apart from each other.

1 Dimensional Thought

Satnam M Singh, The Guru Granth Sahib has SIX yes 6 different places where it specifically says that a Gurmukh sings and dances. So there is absolutely no issue about dancing for a Sikh. But this is not the point of discussion here as this is not even a point of debate (read the leaflet). As always, when dancing is mentioned we get the few Indian Sikhs who have a knee jerk reaction and assume that, those people who are promoting dancing are encouraging dancing in the Diwan Hall, during the Amrit ceremony, whilst reading the Guru Granth Sahib and probably while eating langar too....like hellloooo?? That is not what is being said here! A Gurdwara is and should more be than just a place for meditation. Most Gurdwaras are vibrant social centres too and modern ones are including yoga centres, gym facilities, nursuries, computer rooms, quiet rooms, other sporting facilities etc...so as part of an extended complex of facilities whats wrong with an aerobics /dance studio? The whole idea is to make these institutions more relevant and attractive to young people. If people are coming to a Gurdwara for a much wider range of activities they which have the great good fortune of remaining with Sadh Sangat for longer. The way you posed your question (and I say this with compassion for you) is a good example of the way our community think only in 1 dimension. Blessinsgs and love to you www.ProjectNaad.com

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA,

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH If it is good for the Sikh, it is good for the Guru. So if Sikhs can dance, surely the Punj Pyare can also dance and Guru Gobind Singh Ji of course would have. I assume that this means that the Raagis, the Granthis, the Sewadaars should all get down to some Bhangra in the Diwan right? P.S. What does "cultural dancing" have to do with a "religious place of worship"? When Sikhism has grown out from the Punjab to encompass so many cultures and races, what is the connection of "cultural dancing" (read Bhangra/Gidda) to a Gurudwara? If the Gurudwara is indeed the door to the Guru and the sanctuary of the Sadh Sangat, how does dancing bring people towards that goal? How exactly does doing Bhangra/Gidda facilitate the spiritual progression of a Sikh? So extend this to what exactly does dancing have to do with a Gurudwara? And what music should a Sikh dance to?

whats wrong with cultural dancing?

http://www.projectnaad.com/wp-content/uploads/leaflets/sikh_views_on_dancing.pdf

Dancing?

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH ""Some temples are so strict. There's no cultural dances and plays. They say it's bad to incorporate those things," he said."

Powerless and Taking Control

From my experience doing social work in the community and my local Gurdwara is that if that particular Gurdwara is not listening to you then why are you continuously going there and bankrolling them? They cannot survice without the sangat and we all know that once the chain of continuos migration from arranged marriages and family reunification is stopped they will not have a very long life. It also means if you do not take control then you will probably forget all about your history and culture in the near future. I think the first step is for young baptized sikhs or those seeking baptism (Panch Pyare) to organize their own separate meetings and pool their own funds to create their own Gurdwara. Trust me we can move along a lot faster with our agenda than all the people in sitting in denial in our existing Gurdwara. The only problem you might have us standing up to your family. It is very important that you have young Panch Pyare and educated people to start this plan. Jaskooner

ProjectNaad Flyers

Feel free to print off and display ProjectNaad flyers in your sikh temples. That is something we designed the ProjectNaad Group for to encapsulate all aspects of Sikh Dharma in single A4 page leaflet formats. www.ProjectNaad.com

Excellent and timely article

I know that i was bored at Gurudwara's and all the politics was too much that i eventually stopped going, the same thing has happened to my sister and brother. Gurudwara's must adapt at a much faster pace than they have in the past, they must involve the next generation and involve them in the decision making process, only then will Gurudwara's & Sikh Youth in the west survive. Otherwise who will go to Gurudwara's in 20 years time?

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Email Lists

SikhNet.com Updates Daily Sikh News Daily Hukamnama Unsubscribe