News

Cold comfort at Golden Temple

News Source: www.tribuneindia.com

   Amritsar, May 27 - Despite world-wide criticism from Panthic circles, the Shiromani Gurdwara Prabandhak Committee (SGPC) has installed two air-conditioners (4 tonnes each), one in sanctum sanctorum and the other on the first floor of the Golden Temple.

The conservationists are of the view that air-conditioning will cause colossal “structural damage” to the ancient holy structure of the Darbar Sahib.They said the devotees visited the Darbar Sahib for spiritual solace and not for physical comforts and, hence, they (devotees) had never made any such demand till date. Conservationists are of the view that the walls of the Harmander Sahib are made of burnt bricks and lime mortar and, hence, there was no need to install ACs.

The senior SGPC officials, including Harbhajan Singh, manager, Darbar Sahib, confirmed the installation of ACs in the sanctum sanctorum. The SGPC had formed a sub-committee to look into the effects of the ACs to the ancient structure when its move had received flak from the Sikh sangat the world over.

The move to install the ACs was dropped for a few months when renowned conservationist Gurmit Rai and other Sikh scholars had warned that the air-conditioning system, if introduced in the Darbar Sahib, would be an extremely destructive intervention. Sounding a note of warning, she had stated that the air-conditioning system comprised a blower and a compressor and, hence, while the blower would need to be placed on the floor or mounted on the walls inside the building, the compressor would need to be fixed outside.

These blowers could not be mounted on the walls or the roof without damaging the structure and decorations because of drilling holes or inserting mounting system, she had warned.

Veteran SGPC member Manjit Singh Calcutta described the SGPC decision to install ACs as “ill-conceived”.

The roofing system too is a masonry vaults. The surfaces are extremely decorative, with in-layed marble panel, frescoes or clad with gilded copper embossed sheets. Not even a square inch of plain space can be found on the walls and ceilings to place the ACs without damaging the original structure and decorations.

Decorations will also be at risk due to the variation in the micro climate zones (in temperature and humidity) that will be created inside the building as the doors have to be kept open.

It may be recalled that the SGPC had decided to engage the services of consultants to install ACs in the sanctum sanctorum of the Harmander Sahib, apart from installing security cameras and mobile jammers on the shrine premises in April last year. A decision regarding this was taken at a meeting of the sub-committee, chaired by Raghujit Singh Virk, senior vice-president, SGPC. It is learnt that Surinder Kaur Badal, wife of the Chief Minister of Punjab, has been taking a keen interest in installing modern gadgets in the Golden Temple complex.

By Varinder Walia - Tribune News Service

something to think about!

jdeeps23's picture
If you ask me I think that this is another way to destroy sikhi. For example the whole thing about having chairs in the langer hall at the gurdwara versus sitting on the floor. I wouldn't doubt that some groups like the RSS and currupt people in the Indian government are behind this including Badel and gang. Think about it people how else would you want to cause trouble? I'm not a scientest but I would also like to point out that having A/Cs inside the darbar sahib will cause extreme damage overtime to the construction. This is mentioned already to many people. The polluted air coming outside than into the darbar sahib and than mixing with the chemically driven air by the A/C is really bad. Having electric fans should be enough already. Im not sure but I think some of the raagis at the darbar sahib who are supposedly complaining about it being to hot inside the darbar sahib is just an excuse. I mean come on people, these raagis go home and sit inside there A/C homes all day and than come to the darbar sahib and do keertan and complain how hot it is, hello? of course it's going to feel hot. but that doesn't mean just because of there comfort we should install A/Cs and destroy the darbar sahib. I think one the best solution is controlling the pollution around the Sri Harminder Sahib. Some ways would be by closing factorys down, stop busses that are not running on CNG including 3-wheelers and so on. Basically anything that can cause massive pollution around the darbar sahib. And than after doing that, i'm pretty sure if we put our heads together we can think of a solution to get the sangat from one point to the other, if you know what i'm talking about. WJKK,WJKF

Badal & Co.

Badal And his entire family need to be publicly flogged at Akal Takhat for all the sad things those guys have been doing to sikhi. It's sad when the Gurdwara becomes the personal property of a senile Idiots wife all they can do is run Sri Harmandir Sahib like their own personal Kitty Party Place. SGPC has single handedly managed to do what Indian Army tanks could'nt do, Destroy the Akal Takhat when it could've easily been repaired. The Gurdwara Fatehgarh Sahib where the Chotey Sahibzaade became Shaheed these bunch of fools has managed to pull down the wall where the sahibzaadey were Bricked alive only to replace it with a Golden Palki!!! How sad is the state of sikhi when such people are supposed to be the leaders of our panth!!! Somebody pls make sure these guys are never ever elected even in their own Mohalla Elections. CC: to SGPC

ac's in durbar sahib.

it is part of same mentality which provides heaters and ac's to guru granth sahib to save from heat and cold.how do they differ from brahmins claiming a statue representing God?for more than 400 hundred years,the ragis did not need ac's.are we getting mutant ragis now? or is it to provide comfort to those vip's like badals?i have always prayed to give us vivek and buddhi.looks like we have to intensify that prayer.

Cold comfort or COld Smack

SGPC should be a completely independent of any political influence and should take its own stand when it comes to religious matters. It shouldn't be taking advice from politicians, who don't even know what they are doing. SAD was originally set-up to represent the sikhs in the law-making bodies of the government but it is doing exactly the opposite these days by taking orders from RSS and all those hypocryte organisations, and making the PANTH to follow through with them. How can SAD chose the leader for the NIHANGS? They don't even have any shame in doing playing such idiotic moves in public, its all out in the open and we are doing nothing about it. I think its time we educated anyone we can about these Pakhandi's running these sacred organisations and show them where they really belong. Baaz Singh

This act is the result of

This act is the result of stubborn attitude of the SGPC. They've done because they were determined to do. Any expert ,if ever consulted, appears to be no more than an eye wash. They are supposed to deliver to their grand children,better than what they received from their forefathers. But they are damaging it. It is doubtful that any Raagi might have complained against the temperature inside the sanctum sanctorum( which is very well tolerable in summer because of the sarover around). Can't SGPC think of improving the sound system because during "Asaa Di Vaar" Salok/Paudi being recited by the Tabla player is hardly audible on TV/in Parikarma ?

AC at golden temple

How about monsanto grown food at the langar hall too! maybe it's already there! we'll all be all set .... jiwan jot kaur .

Thoroughly Disgusting

The move to install ACs in the holy Darbar Sahib is thoroughly ill conceived , out of place and a case fit to be taken to court. Mrs Badal thinks she has ownership of the Golden Temple just the way her husband runs the SGPC. This family has ruined the image of sikhs inside india and now , with the little concern they have for anything other than their son and his future , they seem determined to ruin the sikh heritage . Installing AC's in Gurudwaras is a brainchild of myopic and thoroughly wrong understanding of all that this religion really stands for. The Guru doesnt feel hot or cold. The Guru is the Creator . Love for the Almighty is a concept to be lived not to be put as a badge on a chest swollen with false pride. The seeds of this situtaion were sown wen the SAD govt and the SGPC allowed the British queen to enter the Darbar SAhib with socks on. Can the beliefs of our religion be compromised wen it comes to rulers, kings and queens? The very essence and concept of Pangat was defeated that day. The SGPC has not only surrendered to the whims and fancies of the Badal parivaar but has now allowed them to destroy our religion and its symbols. It is time the intelligentsia woke up and put these politicians and their stupid ideas in the bin. Rajbir Singh Research Scholar Mech Engg Deppt Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee India

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Email Lists

SikhNet.com Updates Daily Sikh News Daily Hukamnama Unsubscribe